Short answer
Open grid is generally the simpler approach and suits flat, single-level layouts. L-girder takes a bit more planning but gives you more freedom for hills, valleys and varying elevations. Both are proven, widely used methods, and neither is wrong. The right pick depends on your terrain plans, skills and how much lumber you want to buy.
How open grid works
Open grid benchwork is a rectangular frame with cross members (joists) set in a regular grid, usually topped with plywood or foam board. The frame is supported by legs at the corners and along the sides.
Strengths
- Simple to understand and build, with basic tools.
- Gives a flat, continuous surface for the track and scenery.
- Rigid when properly assembled and braced.
- Easy to modify for a rectangular layout.
Weaknesses
- Uses more lumber than L-girder because of the grid of joists.
- Cutting into the top to lower the terrain, for rivers, valleys or depressed track, can be awkward when joists are in the way.
- The joists can interfere with wiring and turnout machines, so you need to plan where they go.
- A full plywood top may add weight and noise.
How L-girder works
L-girder benchwork uses long girders made from two boards joined in an L shape. The girders run along the length of the layout and are supported by legs. Joists run crosswise on top of the girders, and risers stand on the joists to carry a narrow sub-roadbed under the track. The terrain and scenery can then sit above or below the track.
Strengths
- Flexible for changing elevations, since the sub-roadbed is lifted on risers rather than set on a solid deck.
- Long spans and fewer legs, which can leave more open floor space beneath the layout.
- Easy access from below for wiring and turnout machines, since there is no continuous top.
- Good for river and valley scenes, because the space below the track is open.
Weaknesses
- Needs more planning to place joists and risers correctly.
- More cutting and fitting of riser heights and sub-roadbed.
- A little more difficult for first-time builders.
- Not as convenient for a simple flat layout or a small table.
One builder of a lightweight portable layout used a similar idea on a smaller scale, forming L-shaped and T-shaped girders from 1 by 2 lumber topped with a thin plywood strip. This shows that the girder concept can be scaled down for lightweight projects.
Side-by-side comparison
| Feature | Open grid | L-girder |
|---|---|---|
| Best for | Flat, single-level or table layouts | Layouts with hills, valleys or varied elevation |
| Skill needed | Basic | Moderate |
| Lumber use | Usually more | Usually less |
| Terrain below track | Harder (needs cutouts) | Easier (open below) |
| Underside access | Obstructed by joists | Generally open |
| Typical sub-roadbed | Plywood or foam sheet | Strips on risers, or a sheet on joists |
Terrain and scenery
Your scenery goals often settle the decision. If you want the track to run at a single level with scenery built up on top of the surface, open grid is simpler. If you want valleys, rivers or a clear difference between track elevation and the surrounding ground, L-girder gives you room to build below the track. Multi-level layouts, including a helix, also need a carefully thought out support structure whichever method you pick.
Cost, tools and skill
Prices depend on your local lumber market and how much you buy. As a rough guide, open grid is the less demanding option, and a basic saw, drill, screws and glue will cover it. L-girder uses some of the same tools but expects more accurate cutting and planning. In both cases, straight and dry lumber matters more than the method. For lumber and materials, see our benchwork overview.
Which should you build?
- Choose open grid if you want a flat layout, you are new to woodworking, or you plan a small or table-style layout.
- Choose L-girder if you want hills and valleys, a long layout, or more open space below for access and storage.
- Consider a hybrid if the layout has both a flat yard area and a scenic section. You can use open grid in one area and L-girder elsewhere, or use a plywood top on a girder frame where terrain is flat.
- Think about space-saving designs such as shelf or fold-down layouts. They have different needs, and are covered in space-saving layouts.
Once the frame is built, the next step is the track base and rail. See laying model railroad track.