Benchwork and Track

Is it cheaper to build a road or train track?

Whether a road or a railway is cheaper to build depends on terrain, capacity and scope. Here is what drives costs, plus the model railroad version of the question.

On this page
  1. Short answer
  2. What drives cost for full-size roads and railways
  3. What one cost study found
  4. Think about cost per user, not just per mile
  5. On a model railroad: roads or track?

Short answer

It depends. There is no single answer, because the cost of either one swings widely with terrain, location, how many lanes or tracks you build, and what the project includes. A simple at-grade road across open land is a very different project from a tunneled urban rail line, and the opposite comparison is also true.

What drives cost for full-size roads and railways

Both involve many of the same costs:

  • Land and right-of-way, which can dominate costs in built-up areas.
  • Earthworks and drainage, which depend heavily on terrain.
  • Structures, such as bridges, tunnels and overpasses.
  • Surface and track: pavement for roads, and ballast, ties and rails for railways.
  • Systems: railways may need signaling and, in some cases, electrification, while roads need lighting, signs and similar equipment.
  • Design, management and legal processes, which can be large in many countries.

Capacity is also important. A road with a handful of lanes and a rail line with a few tracks carry very different numbers of passengers and amounts of freight, so comparing cost per mile alone can be misleading.

What one cost study found

The High Speed Rail Alliance reported on research from the NYU Transit Costs Project, which tracks urban rail costs across many countries. The research examined transit projects, not roads or freight railways, so its numbers do not settle the road versus rail question. Findings included:

  • The United States ranks as the sixth most expensive country in the world for building transit infrastructure, according to the project, and tunneled track is a major cost factor.
  • New York’s Second Avenue subway was reported at about $2.6 billion per mile, compared with about $800 million per mile for the Purple Line in Los Angeles. Projects in Madrid and Paris were reported at about $320 million and $160 million per mile.
  • The same article noted that highway construction costs have also risen sharply in recent decades, and that the problem affects every form of transportation in the United States.
  • The researchers pointed to factors such as the use of consultants, the number of workers on a project, a lack of standardization and the many stakeholders involved.

The takeaway is that cost depends more on how a project is planned and delivered than on whether it carries cars or trains.

Think about cost per user, not just per mile

Road and rail also differ in what the money buys. A rail line may carry many passengers or large freight volumes on a narrow footprint, while a road offers flexible, door-to-door access for many different vehicles. Which is cheaper per person or per ton depends on usage, so planners generally compare costs over time and across the service provided. We cannot give a general ratio.

On a model railroad: roads or track?

If you are asking about your own layout, the question becomes more practical. The cost depends on what you use:

In general, a simple scenic road is cheaper than the same length of track plus wiring (our HO layout cost guide breaks down the bigger picture), but prices vary by brand and materials, so compare current prices for the products you intend to use.

The complete guide to benchwork and track

Model Railroad Benchwork and Platform Construction
Read the guide

Keep exploring

Guides from other topics

All topics →