Water options compared
Water is often seen as the hardest scenery to model, but modern products have made it easier than it used to be. The main choices fall into a few groups.
Two-part epoxy resin (for example, EnviroTex or Magic Water are products commonly mentioned by modellers). These produce a hard, glossy, glass-like surface that suits still water. They are mixed in measured amounts and poured. They need a well-sealed, level bed, because liquid resin can leak through any gap. Always follow the manufacturer’s safety instructions, work in a ventilated space, and wear gloves and eye protection.
Ready-made water products. Woodland Scenics, Busch and other makers sell water-effect products in several forms, including pour-on or brush-on water that you build up in layers, and gel or ripple products for moving water. These are usually easier to handle than epoxy.
Acrylic gloss medium or gel. Gloss acrylic mediums are inexpensive, go on white and dry clear. They can be built up in thin coats, and brushing or stippling creates ripples. Gels are thicker and are good for rapids and waterfalls.
Rippled plastic sheets. Pre-formed sheets or films from makers such as Busch, Faller, Kibri or Noch can be cut to shape and laid in place. They give consistent ripple patterns but may need edges disguised.
For still water, many modellers prefer resin or pour-on products for the glossiest finish. For streams and rapids, acrylic medium or gel gives more control over movement. You can also combine them: a pour or gloss surface for the pond, with ripples near the shore added in gloss medium.
Plan the water scene
Before you cut or glue anything:
- Choose the type of water. A still pond, a lazy river, a fast mountain stream and a harbour all look different.
- Give streams a source and a destination. A stream should not start or end in the middle of a field. It might come from a hillside, pass under a bridge, and disappear behind a hill, trees or the backdrop.
- Use reference photos. Look at real photos of the kind of water you are modelling. Colour, clarity, bank shape and rocks are all easier to copy from a picture than to invent.
- Think about what lies underneath. Track, wiring and benchwork are all easier to plan around before the bed is built.
Build and seal the bed
The bed is the shallow depression that will hold the water. Many modellers cut it into a thick layer of extruded foam, or build it up with plaster cloth or similar around the edges.
- Cut or shape the depression. Make it deep enough for the water layer plus your banks. Taper banks to be steeper or more gradual, as appropriate.
- Line the bed with plaster cloth or a similar material, and smooth the surface. A little extra Hydrocal or plaster over the cloth helps cover the fibres.
- Let it dry fully, then sand smooth.
- Fill gaps and pinholes with plaster or spackling compound. This step matters most for resin, because any gap can let it escape.
- Seal the bed with paint or a sealer suitable for your chosen water product.
A pond bed should be flat and level, even if the surrounding land is not. A stream bed can be irregular, because moving water follows the terrain. Sculptamold or similar compounds work well for rougher stream beds.
Paint the bed
Painting the bed is what gives the water depth. Real water is not a flat sheet of blue. It reveals the bottom near the edge and looks darker where it is deep.
- Prime the bed in flat black or very dark brown.
- Paint the deepest area darkest. Add small amounts of green, blue-grey or brown for a natural colour, rather than a bright sky blue or vivid green.
- Lighten toward the edges. Blend lighter, more earth-toned colours toward the banks, as shallower water shows more of the bottom.
- Stipple the edge where bed colour meets bank colour so the transition is soft.
For streams, moving water is often muddy, so green-brown or grey-brown tones may work better than blue. Match colours to your reference photos.
Place details such as submerged rocks, sunken logs, weeds and small stones before you add the water surface. Cast rock and boulders, such as those described in casting plaster rock faces, can also be used along banks.
Ponds and lakes
Still water needs a smooth, level surface. After painting and detailing:
- For resin, mix exactly as the manufacturer directs and pour a thin layer, usually in stages. Pop or remove surface bubbles gently as directed by the instructions, and keep dust off while it cures.
- For pour-on or brush-on water products, follow the label, and apply thin layers, allowing each to dry before the next. Thick single coats may cloud, crack or wrinkle.
- For acrylic gloss medium, brush on thin coats, allowing each to dry. It dries clear and can be built up gradually.
Patience is the key. Several thin layers usually look better than one thick one.
Streams and rivers
Streams give the most interesting results because the water moves.
- Vary the width. Narrower in some places, wider in others, with bends.
- Add rocks in and at the edges of the stream. Water breaks and ripples around them.
- Add fallen branches or logs at the edge.
- Run the stream under bridges and culverts, so the structure sits in the scene properly.
When the bed is finished, brush on gloss acrylic medium. Brush strokes and stippling create ripples. Downstream from a rock or branch the water is more agitated, with ripples tapering to a point behind the obstacle.
Ripples, rapids and waterfalls
Gel mediums and thicker products can be dabbed with a stick or brush to form peaks. White paint, applied lightly, suggests foam around rocks and at the base of falls. For waterfalls, specialised products or clear strips are available, and modellers also build falls from layers of gloss medium and a little white paint, drawn down the rock face. Keep white subtle. Too much looks like icing.
Finish the shoreline
The edge where water meets land is where the scene succeeds or fails.
- Hide the edge of the water layer with ground cover, small stones, mud-coloured earth, reeds, cattails and weeds.
- Darken the bank just above the water line, as wet earth is darker.
- Add trees or bushes that lean over the water. For more on this, see making realistic model railroad trees.
- Add people and objects such as boats, fishermen or swimmers, sparingly.
For the ground cover and bank techniques that surround water scenes, see DIY model railroad scenery.
Troubleshooting
- Leaks. Seal the bed fully before pouring resin. If in doubt, test with a small amount of water first.
- Cloudy or milky finish. This is often caused by applying a thick coat or by moisture. Use thin coats and allow proper drying.
- Cracks or wrinkles in acrylic. These come from layers that were too thick. Build up gradually.
- Bubbles. Mix resin slowly, and follow the product’s advice for removing bubbles.
- Water looks like glass sheet. Add depth through painting, ripples near edges, and objects in the water.
- Edges look obvious. Soften with ground cover, rocks and plants.