Benchwork and Track

Cork vs Foam Roadbed: Which Is Better for Model Track?

Compare cork and foam roadbed for model railroad track: noise, fastening, curves, cost and ease of use, with guidance on which to choose.

On this page
  1. Short answer
  2. What roadbed does
  3. Cork roadbed
  4. Foam roadbed
  5. Side-by-side comparison
  6. What reduces noise?
  7. Fixing and curves
  8. Which to pick

Short answer

Neither is better in every situation. Cork is the traditional choice and is easy to nail or pin, which suits handlaid and spiked track and layouts where you want to adjust things later. Foam is generally quieter and easy to cut, and many modellers like it for ready-to-run layouts. Your track type, your benchwork and how much noise bothers you decide the best fit.

What roadbed does

Roadbed is the raised strip between the sub-roadbed (plywood or foam board) and the track. It:

  • Lifts the track slightly and forms a sloped shoulder for ballast.
  • Provides a bit of cushioning, which can reduce noise.
  • Helps the track sit evenly on the benchwork.

If you have not yet decided on the structure below the roadbed, see model railroad benchwork.

Cork roadbed

Advantages

  • A long history and wide availability.
  • Takes track nails and pins well, which suits adjustable, non-glued installation. One forum member described sliding cork roadbed under loose track, nailing it at the edges with track nails and then securing the track with small screws, so that changes were easy and parts could be reused.
  • Provides a firm base for ballast.

Drawbacks

  • It can be a little noisier than rubber or foam products, depending on the setup.
  • It tends to be stiffer, so tight curves often call for cork that is cut or split to follow the curve.
  • Cork can crumble if it is cut with dull tools.

Foam roadbed

Advantages

  • Typically quieter. Modellers commonly report that foam roadbed reduces train noise.
  • Easy to cut and shape.
  • Often flexible enough for curves, though very tight curves might need slicing. One forum member said they needed only occasional cuts on broad curves but many on a tighter radius.
  • Some products work without ballast, since the edges are angled to blend into the surface.

Drawbacks

  • You cannot easily screw or pin the track into foam, so track is usually glued, or secured with ties that go through to a harder layer below. One forum member put Homasote under the foam, so screws could go into the Homasote.
  • It is not a cure-all for noise. Some snap-together systems with a hollow base stay loud, even over foam.
  • Product length, thickness and profile differ between brands, so check that the roadbed matches your track’s width and scale.

Side-by-side comparison

Feature Cork Foam
Noise Moderate Generally quieter
Fastening Nails and pins work well Mostly glue
Curves May need split or cut cork Usually flexes easily, with slicing for tighter curves
Adjustability Good if pinned Harder to adjust once glued
Best for Handlaid and spiked track, adjustable layouts Ready-to-run track, quiet running

What reduces noise?

Roadbed is one part. Noise also depends on the surface it sits on and the track system. Plywood can act like a soundboard, so some modellers add an insulating layer such as Homasote or use a resilient roadbed. Fixing the track firmly but not rigidly, and avoiding gaps, helps too. Anything that couples the track directly to a hollow surface may amplify sound.

Fixing and curves

Whichever you choose, lay roadbed along the centerline you marked, and make sure the joints do not line up with the track joints. Smooth, gradual curves are easier on both materials, and our guide to bending flex track into smooth curves explains how to lay the track once the roadbed is down. For the overall process, see laying model railroad track.

Which to pick

  • Choose cork if you plan to spike or nail track, you want to adjust things later, or you want the traditional approach.
  • Choose foam if you want quieter running, you intend to glue the track, or you want an easy-to-cut material.
  • Consider both in different areas. Some modellers use one on the main line and another in hidden areas, and others skip roadbed in yards.

Because brands and thicknesses differ, buy a sample of the product you are considering, and test it on a short length of track before buying in bulk.

The complete guide to benchwork and track

Model Railroad Benchwork and Platform Construction
Read the guide

Keep exploring

Guides from other topics

All topics →