Layout Planning

Time Saver Switching Puzzles: How They Work and How to Build One

What a Time Saver switching puzzle is, how the game works, where it came from, and tips for building one, plus how it compares with the Inglenook puzzle.

On this page
  1. Short answer
  2. Where it came from
  3. How it works
  4. How to play
  5. Building one
  6. Related puzzles
  7. Tips

Short answer

A Time Saver is a small switching layout designed as a puzzle. A locomotive has to move freight cars between several short tracks so that each car ends up in a specified place, following a list of instructions. The classic version is credited to John Allen, the model railroader known for his Gorre & Daphetid layout. It is a challenge of planning and skill rather than scenery.

Where it came from

The Time Saver appeared in the model railroad press in the mid-twentieth century and became a staple of shelf-switcher and club layouts. It is often paired in articles with the Inglenook, a British shunting puzzle. Both are popular because they pack a lot of operating interest into very little space. For more on switching layouts in general, see switching layout plans and car cards.

How it works

A Time Saver combines a few things:

  • A lead (switching lead), where the locomotive can pull cars out of the way
  • A runaround or similar way to get the locomotive to the other end of the cars
  • A handful of spurs of different lengths, each serving an industry
  • A set of cars that start in particular positions

The puzzle comes from a switch list, which tells you which cars to move to which spurs. Because the spurs are short and the cars must be placed in particular spots, you need to plan your moves carefully. A poor plan means extra moves and wasted time. The aim of the original game is to complete the list quickly and with the fewest unnecessary moves, hence the name.

How to play

  1. Set up the cars in their starting positions.
  2. Draw or deal a switch list, which says where each car must go.
  3. Plan your moves before you start.
  4. Switch the cars with the locomotive, following the rules you set, such as not leaving cars on the lead or the main.
  5. Time the run, or count moves, and try to improve your score.

You can write your own rules. Some players draw cards or roll dice to generate a new puzzle every time. Others play it as a relaxed pastime without timing.

Building one

A Time Saver can be built in a narrow space, and the size depends on your scale. Points to consider:

  • Scale. Smaller scales let you fit the puzzle on a shorter board. HO versions are longer than N versions of the same design. See compact layouts for space-saving ideas.
  • Turnouts. Choose turnouts that work reliably with the cars you plan to use. Because the puzzle involves constant switching, poor turnouts will be a constant annoyance.
  • Track lengths. Make each spur long enough for the number of cars you intend to place, and plan the lead so that the locomotive can pull cars clear of the turnouts.
  • Couplers. Reliable couplers are essential. Many puzzle builders use couplers that can be uncoupled easily by hand or magnet.
  • Access. Make sure you can reach every track to rerail cars.
  • Wiring. Keep it simple, with reliable electrical contact on every track (see how many track feeders you need). Dead spots make switching frustrating.

You can use track planning software or draw the plan by hand. See planning your model railroad for general advice on drawing and testing a plan.

The Inglenook has a headshunt and three sidings of different lengths. A common version asks you to assemble a short train of cars in a random order, using only the headshunt and sidings. It is simpler than a Time Saver and a good starting point.

Other designs add more tracks, industries or operating rules. Some layouts also combine puzzle features with car card operations for more varied sessions.

Tips

  • Start with fewer cars than the track can hold, so you have room to move.
  • Keep the puzzle fun. Too many cars and too little track can be frustrating.
  • Consider a fiddle yard or cassette to swap in new sets of cars.
  • Practice a few times before you judge the layout.

The complete guide to layout planning

Planning Your Model Railroad: Track Plan Design from Scratch
Read the guide

Keep exploring

Guides from other topics

All topics →